Pet Store Inventory Management

Intro

Owning a pet store can be profitable — especially with more people bringing animals into their homes. Today, 77% of pet parents say financial uncertainty hasn’t changed how much or how often they spend on their pets.

But selling products doesn’t guarantee you’ll make a profit.

A $60 bag of dog food might bring customers in, but with thin margins, that sale nets you maybe $3 to $5. That doesn’t cover rent. And it definitely doesn’t help your business grow.

Real profit often comes from higher-margin items — toys, accessories, and services that encourage impulse buys or build customer loyalty. While many of these products are available elsewhere, your ability to offer expert advice, convenience, and a curated experience is what sets your store apart.

This guide will help you rethink how you stock, sell, and manage your inventory. You'll learn how to:

Free up cash stuck in low-margin products
Reduce waste from expired items
Improve cash flow
Build a margin mix that works — even during slow months

Done right, smart inventory management can turn your shop into the go-to destination for all things pet — not just a stop for kibble.

The “Dog Food Trap”: It’s Costing You More Than You Think

Stocking a wide variety of dog food might seem like good customer service. Grain-free, breed-specific, organic, raw, fresh, freeze-dried. The more options, the better — right?

Not really.

Here’s why expanding your dog food selection too much can hurt your business:

Thin margins: Dog food typically earns just 5–10% profit. On a $50 bag, that’s $3 to $5.
Shelf life: Food expires. More SKUs = more spoilage. Plus, fresh or frozen options require expensive refrigeration equipment, adding another layer of cost.
Holding costs: Inventory costs you even if it sits. Pet stores pay 20% to 30% of product value annually to store, move, and manage stock.
Lost space: A shelf of $25 collars with a 50% margin makes far more profit than bulk food and uses less floor space.
Cash flow pressure: Cash tied up in low-margin products leaves less to invest in better-selling pet products or prepare for seasonal changes.

Food itself isn’t a trap, but letting it dominate your shelves is.

Turn Pet Food Into a Sales Gateway

Food still matters — it gets customers in the door. But that can’t be where the sale ends.

It’s estimated that 40% to 80% of all purchases are the result of impulse buys, especially when customers shop for everyday essentials like food. Use that to your advantage by placing high-margin add-ons within reach.

Here’s how to increase the value of each visit:

Pair kibble with slow feeder bowls, puzzle toys, or toppers.
Stock chews and treats near checkout.
Display collars, seasonal gear, or leashes near food aisles.

Now that you know diversifying your product mix is key, here’s how the margins typically break down for common pet store products and services — and why it matters.

The problem

Smarter Margin Mix = Stronger Cash Flow

When your inventory is filled mostly with fast-moving, low-profit items like pet food, you’ll have less flexibility to:

Bring in seasonal or trending products.
Turn inventory into cash quickly.
Handle slow periods or unexpected cost hikes.

A strategic shift toward a smarter margin mix can ease these challenges and strengthen your cash flow.

Margins typically look like this:

Pet food: 4% to 10%
Pet toys, collars, and accessories: 30% to 50%
Premium treats: 40%+
Supplements and specialty products: up to 60%
Services (grooming, training, delivery): 50% to 70%

To visualize the impact:

Selling 100 bags of pet food at $60 each totals $6,000 in sales. With a 7% margin, that’s $420 profit.

Selling 60 pet leashes at $25 each totals $1,500 in sales. With a 45% margin, that’s $675 profit.

Same effort, 60% more profit.

Focus your floor space and staff attention on accessories and services.

Give Your Pet Products a Purpose

"If I don’t pack my shelves with food, then what do I do?" Great question.

Every product in your store should do one of three things:

Bring customers in (traffic drivers)
Generate profit (profit drivers)
Build loyalty (relationship builders)

Here’s how to think about your inventory mix — and what percentage of your stock to allocate to each:

Traffic Drivers
(30–35%)

These are essentials like dog food, cat litter, and waste bags. They don’t earn much profit, but get customers through your door. Once inside, your inventory mix and product placement can do their job.

In action: Joan comes in for her usual 50lb bag of kibble. While there, she mentions that her bulldog, Buddy, hasn’t been eating as much lately. You suggest toppers and puzzle feeders nearby. On her way out, she picks a gourmet treat — what started as $45 becomes $65, with better profit.

Profit Drivers
(40%)

This is where your store makes real money. Toys, treats, collars, and grooming tools don’t always move as fast as food, but they pack more margin into every sale.

In action: Marco comes in for some high-value treats to use while training his new puppy. On the way to checkout, he notices a display of leashes and collars designed specifically for training. That old harness hasn’t been doing much — his pup still pulls like crazy on walks.

He ends up investing in a Herm Sprenger collar and a premium leather lead that’ll last through his dog’s first few growth spurts. Now that he’s seen what’s available, Marco knows he can return to your store as his puppy grows — and his training needs change.

Relationship Builders
(10–20%)

Products that solve problems and build trust, like prescription diets, calming sprays, specialty shampoos don’t fly off the shelves — but when they do, they create loyalty.

In action: Melissa’s Bengal cat has separation anxiety and turns the sofa into a scratching post and the rug into a litter box anytime Melissa leaves the house. You recommend a pheromone spray and book grooming appointments. Melissa becomes a regular because you helped, instead of just trying to sell products. She even returns for litter box advice.

Setting your margin mix accurately helps you gain more cash flow over time, but you’ll need to know how to manage it. Keep reading for other tips to better manage your cash flow so you don’t run out of money at the worst time.

7 Smarter Inventory Strategies for Better Cash Flow

Setting your margin mix gives you more control over your profits — but smart cash flow management is what keeps your business stable through every season.

Running out of cash at the wrong moment can do serious damage.

Think:

Right before the holidays, when you need to stock up.
During slow months, when fixed costs don’t slow down.
When a vendor raises prices, and you can’t afford to restock.
After you’ve invested in a new service or equipment.
Or when your freezer breaks and you need a fix — fast.

To avoid getting caught off guard, use these strategies to keep your cash flow steady year-round.

Inventory Strategies

1. Make Every Square Foot Count

Your floor space is valuable real estate. Prioritize high-margin products in high-traffic spots to maximize profit per square foot.

Display profitable items up front: Items like premium collars, treats, or grooming tools. Tuck low-margin staples like bulk food or litter in less visible areas.
Encourage impulse buys: Place small accessories and seasonal add-ons near checkout.
Tie displays to services: Put brushes and shampoos near grooming pickup. When pets leave looking great, customers are more likely to buy the products that helped.
Keep larger items in the stockroom: Big items like XL dog crates or tall cat scratching posts don’t need to take up valuable floor space. Display just one with a note that more are available — and encourage customers to ask an associate for help.

Example:

10 sq ft of floor space featuring $30 collars at a 50% margin = $150 in profit per 10 units. Using the same space for $50 dog food at a 5% margin yields just $25 profit.

That’s a $125 difference — just from better placement.

Related Read: 12 Unique Pet Shop Display Ideas

2. Plan for Seasonal Peaks and Lulls

Some products move fast in certain seasons, others sit. Know what to stock — and when.

Holidays: Order pet gifts, apparel, and treats four to six weeks in advance.
Spring: Stock flea/tick preventatives and grooming tools three to six months ahead.
Summer travel: Restock water bowls, seat covers, and carriers two to four weeks before peak season.

Use strong sales months to carry you through slower periods. Subscription models or delivery services for nearly any pet product can also help generate steady income during lulls.

3. Negotiate With Vendors

Make sure to ask your vendors about all their payment terms and negotiate accordingly.

For expensive items like premium dog beds or grooming equipment, request extended terms upfront. For fast-moving basics like dog food, standard terms work fine since you'll sell it quickly.

Pro Tip: Order seasonal items (flea treatments, winter gear) with extended terms. This lets you stock up without an immediate cash impact.

As you build rapport with vendors and submit more purchase orders, vendors will be more likely to offer you more favorable terms.

Related Read: How To Choose & Manage Pet Store Vendors [+ 5 Top Vendors]

4. Manage Perishables Before They Cost You

Products with shelf lives — like fresh food or natural treats — need close monitoring. Don’t let them expire on your shelves.

If items are getting close to expiration:

Offer free samples to move products.
Bundle with popular items ("Buy dog food, get free natural treats").
Donate to local shelters for a tax write-off.
Mark down 30% to 50% rather than lose everything.

Move it before you lose it.

5. Plan for Emergencies

Cash flow crunches will happen. Be ready.

Mark down expensive items by 20-30%: That $200 dog bed sitting for months needs to go.
Bundle slow-movers with popular items: "Buy dog food, get 50% off this leash."
Push grooming appointments: Generate immediate cash and book future revenue.
Contact prescription diet customers early: Ask them to refill before they run out.
Liquidate seasonal leftovers: Halloween costumes in November won't sell in spring.

A quick response keeps problems from compounding.

6. “Liquidation” Can Work in Your Favor

Liquidation doesn’t have to mean desperation. A planned sale can create urgency and drive volume — without hurting your brand.

Use bundles or “limited time” offers to move stale stock.
Avoid deep discounts on core items to preserve perceived value.
Gift leftover items to top customers or loyalty members as a perk.
Use themed sales (“Clear the Shelves,” “Spring Clean Specials”) to make it feel intentional.

Done right, clearance drives traffic and loyalty.

7. Use Services to Boost Cash Flow

When product sales dip, services can help fill the gap.

Push grooming before the holidays or spring.
Promote boarding ahead of travel seasons.
Use slow months to cross-sell: “Book a nail trim, get 15% off brushes.”

Services are margin-rich and cash-friendly — don’t let that revenue stream go underused.

Up next: Learn how to apply everything you've just read with a simple 90-day rollout plan — so you can build a more profitable store without the overwhelm.

Put What You Learned Into Practice

Inventory management is a continuous process, so you don’t need to do everything all at once. Start with foundational changes and build up to more detailed adjustments over time.

Week 1-2: Start With the Basics

Reorganize your store layout: Move high-margin items like premium pet toys, grooming tools, or specialty treats to prime spots. Keep dog food where customers expect it, but don't give it your best real estate.
Evaluate key products: Focus on adjusting your inventory mix for immediate impact. Review which categories — like accessories or health-related items — are driving profits and make sure they’re well-stocked and easy for customers to find.

Week 3-4: Train Your Staff

Work with your team to shift the conversation with customers from price to value, especially when it comes to premium products like high-end pet food, specialty collars, or orthopedic pet beds.

When someone buys dog food, staff should mention grooming appointments or suggest higher-margin treats. Train them on pet expertise, not just sales — customers trust knowledgeable staff.

Month 2: Track What Changes

Track performance regularly: Use your POS data to see which layout changes work. Are customers buying more accessories? Are grooming bookings increasing? Your POS system’s reporting shows exactly what's working.
Adjust inventory mix as you go: Gradually test adding new categories, like high-end pet beds or eco-friendly pet products, or phasing out underperforming items like low-margin grooming tools. Small, thoughtful shifts will make a difference over time.

Month 3: Negotiate With Vendors

Negotiate based on your new strategy: With your inventory mix clearer, start renegotiating with vendors. Initially, focus on key categories like premium pet food, durable toys, or seasonal products.
Adapt terms for growth: As your sales data accumulates, use it to negotiate better terms with vendors, such as extended payment periods or bulk discounts for high-margin items like luxury pet accessories or specialty health products.

Refine Over Time

Test new categories gradually: Once you’ve established your core categories, consider experimenting with new ones over time. These could be unique items like interactive pet toys or premium grooming tools.
Phase out slow movers: After assessing performance regularly, start phasing out products that don’t sell. Gradually adjust your strategy as you see what works and what doesn’t, making smaller tweaks instead of overhauling everything at once.

It's okay if it feels like a lot — implementing new processes takes time. Don’t be afraid to dive into the data or chat with your customers. Pay attention to what they love about your store and where you can improve. And remember, checking out nearby competition can give you insights on how to create a product mix that’s unbeatable.

What's next?

Get Smarter Inventory Management with eTailPet

Following the tips in this guide will help you bring in more revenue and profit, weather slow periods, and attract more customers with the right product mix. Having the right technology will only help you manage your inventory even better.

eTailPet is a point of sale (POS) system built specifically for pet store owners. It simplifies inventory management with tools that give you full visibility of your stock and make day-to-day operations easier.

Smart ordering helps you track what’s selling, so you know when it’s time to restock. The system also provides comprehensive reports, offering a clear view of your business and allowing you to make data-driven decisions.

Plus, you’ll have access to a catalog of thousands of pet products that’s regularly updated. This helps you manage vendor relationships and ensures you don’t order items that may have been recalled or discontinued.

With eTailPet, you can stay on top of your inventory, reduce manual tasks, and focus more on what matters most — serving customers and growing your business. It combines easy-to-use features with smart technology, built to meet the needs of pet store owners looking to take control of their inventory and grow with confidence.

Click to schedule a free demo of the premier POS system and inventory management software available.

How Smart Choices Help Your Business Grow