By 
Big-box stores may have national name recognition, but local pet stores have something more valuable: trust, expertise, and community. You know your regulars by name. You stock the specialty diets their pets rely on. And when an emergency comes up, you’re the one they call, not a chain retailer.
That kind of loyalty is powerful. The right marketing strategies can make it even stronger, especially when they highlight what makes your store different.
Below are actionable, pet store marketing ideas to help you stand out, connect with your customers, and compete with the chains. Each idea includes clear, practical steps to help you get started. Plus, you’ll learn how to maximize the tools you already have — especially if you’re using a point of sale (POS) system designed specifically for pet stores.
Let’s dive in.
The Resurgence of Shopping Local: 9 Smart Marketing Ideas for Pet Stores
Shoppers are becoming more intentional about where they spend their money — and many are shifting away from big-box chains. While national retailers may offer competitive prices, they often come with crowded aisles, undertrained staff, and a lack of personal service.
A growing number of consumers are willing to spend up to $150 more each month to support local businesses that bring life back to their main streets. And for every $100 spent at a local shop, about $68 stays in the community — a much higher return than chain stores offer.
This shift is good news for independent pet retailers. You have the expertise and the relationships that big chains can’t replicate. Here are nine marketing strategies that make those strengths even stronger — and help keep your store top-of-mind with pet parents in your area.
1. Offer Same-Day Delivery for Pet Emergencies
Big-box stores can’t match the speed or personal service of a local shop. Offering same-day or next-day delivery helps customers when they run out of food, litter, or pee pads. These moments create loyalty if you’re the one who shows up.
Plus, using the same delivery driver builds trust. It gives your store a face and helps customers feel safer about who’s approaching their door. Unlike national services, you’re not sending a stranger every time or risking damaged packages.
How to implement it:
- Set delivery boundaries based on zip code or mileage.
- Use your POS system to manage inventory visibility and ensure products are in stock.
- Promote emergency delivery in email footers, on your homepage, and on social media.
- Include signage in-store reminding shoppers of this perk.
How your POS helps:
If your POS platform integrates with your e-commerce and inventory systems, you can show real-time product availability and trigger low-stock alerts — so customers only order what you can actually deliver.
2. Send Automated Emails for Pet Birthdays & Adoption Days
People love celebrating their pets, and the numbers back it up. Over 70% of millennial and Gen Z pet owners celebrate pet birthdays or adoption anniversaries — and many spend $50 or more on treats, toys, or experiences.
Sending a personalized offer tied to a pet’s birthday or adoption day (often called a “gotcha day”) adds a thoughtful touch that brings people back. It also gives customers a reason to look forward to shopping with you each year.
How to implement it:
- Ask for pet details (name, type, birthday/gotcha day) at checkout or during account sign-up.
- Use automated workflows to send a special reward or discount annually.
- Invite customers to enter a photo contest or tag your store on social media.
How your POS helps:
A modern system stores pet profiles and purchase history, which you can segment by date to trigger timely, relevant campaigns.
3. Segment Customers by Pet Type & Purchase History
A first-time puppy owner isn’t shopping for the same things as someone with an aging cat. Segmenting customers by pet type or past shopping behavior helps you deliver more relevant emails, recommendations, and promotions — which leads to better engagement and stronger sales.
How to implement it:
- Group customers by pet type, life stage, or shopping habits.
- Send targeted campaigns based on what they’ve bought in the past.
- Run seasonal or care-focused campaigns (like flea and tick reminders for dog owners).
How your POS helps:
If your POS system captures pet data and purchase trends, you can set up smart segments that update automatically without manual spreadsheets.
4. Highlight Your Expertise on Specialized Pet Diets
Nutrition is one of the top concerns for pet owners — especially those dealing with allergies, weight issues, or breed-specific needs. And while people can Google anything, it often leads to conflicting advice.
When this happens, they want to talk to someone they trust. Your product knowledge becomes a key reason customers choose your store. Make sure that expertise shows up in your marketing.
How to implement it:
- Host an in-store or virtual workshop on how to read pet food labels.
- Create a blog or video series on specialty diets (raw, grain-free, limited ingredient, etc.).
- Use shelf talkers or signage to explain why certain products are better for specific needs.
How your POS helps:
Using a comprehensive POS system, track top-selling items in specialty diet categories, then leverage that data to promote relevant products to the customers who are most likely to care about them.
Related Read: How To Store Pet Food in Your Retail Store
5. Host Community Events That Create Real Connections
Events give customers a reason to visit that goes beyond restocking supplies. They’re also a great opportunity to partner with local rescues, trainers, or vets. These partnerships can expand your reach and strengthen your ties within the community.
How to implement it:
- Partner with a local shelter for an adoption event or fundraiser.
- Host a pet photo booth or costume contest tied to a holiday.
- Invite experts for live Q&A sessions or training demos.
How your POS helps:
Your POS system can simplify event promotion by allowing you to send emails, SMS (if enabled), and post on social media — all from one place. You can also create a custom event webpage with partner details and RSVP instructions, making it easy for customers to access all the info they need.
After the event, your POS helps track customer engagement by linking profiles to attendance and sign-ups. You can follow up with personalized messages or special offers, while also managing and encouraging reviews to further boost your community impact.
Promotion tip: Create flyers to display in other local businesses, post on social media, and email your list 2–3 weeks in advance. Send a reminder the day before and offer attendees an exclusive in-store discount.
6. Offer a Loyalty Program That Rewards Regulars
If your customers are buying the same food every four weeks, give them a reason to stick with you. Loyalty programs that reward repeat purchases, referrals, or specific product lines make it easier for customers to keep coming back.
How to implement it:
- Set up a points-based system for purchases, referrals, or social shares.
- Personalize rewards based on shopping habits or pet needs.
- Display reward balances at checkout or on receipts.
How your POS helps:
With a solid system, you get built-in loyalty tools that let you automatically track points, issue rewards, and apply them at checkout — no manual entry needed.
Related Read: Pet Store Customer Loyalty 101: The What, Why, and How
7. Schedule Social Media Content in Batches
You don’t need to post on social media every day, but you do need consistency. Scheduling posts in advance helps you stay active without having to constantly log in and create content on the fly.
One way to stay organized is by building a weekly content schedule. This gives your team a roadmap and helps eliminate the daily question of “what should we post today?”
For example:
- Mondays: Highlight new arrivals.
- Tuesdays: Share pet owner tips (like “indoor activities for high-energy dogs”).
- Wednesdays: Feature staff favorites or product spotlights.
- Thursdays: Provide care advice or grooming how-tos.
- Fridays: Create a recurring series (e.g., “Feline Fridays” featuring cat-specific products or tips).
- Weekends: Showcase community posts, store updates, or user-generated content (UGC).
You still want to leave space for on-the-fly content, but having a basic schedule in place saves time and keeps your posts balanced.
How to implement it:
- Set aside time weekly or monthly to plan and schedule content.
- Build a rotating schedule with predictable content categories.
- Use location tags and relevant hashtags to increase local visibility.
- Include clear calls-to-action when featuring products.
How your POS helps:
If your POS platform includes social scheduling tools, you can pull product images, pricing, and descriptions directly into your posts. This helps you move faster and ensures your promotions are accurate and aligned across channels.
Related Read: Social Media Marketing for Pet Stores: 15 Creative Ideas
8. Turn Your Pet Store Into a Content Hub
Useful content helps establish your store as a trusted resource. Whether it’s a blog post or short video, it also gives you helpful material to share via email or social media.
How to implement it:
- Write blog posts that answer common pet questions.
- Create simple videos demonstrating how products work or how to use them.
- Repost UGC (with permission).
Topics to consider:
- How to choose the right harness for your dog
- What to feed a picky senior cat
- Best toys for energetic puppies
How your POS helps:
Your POS system can make content creation easier by allowing you to build custom content pages on your website. You can use these pages to answer FAQs, address common pet concerns, and create educational guides that engage your customers.
You can also embed videos on these pages or link to them in your marketing emails and social media posts, which makes the content easy for your audience to access. Plus, a robust POS allows you to repost UGC — like customer photos, reviews, or pet stories — strengthening your connection with the community.
9. Promote Your Local Advantage
When customers walk into your store, they should feel like they’re somewhere familiar. Somewhere that reflects the neighborhood instead of a generic chain.
Think about a well-loved local diner — the kind with photos of hometown legends and signed jerseys from the pro team. People connect with places that feel like part of the community. Your pet store can do the same.
Use your marketing and your physical space to show what makes your business different. That can mean spotlighting your team, promoting services big-box stores can’t match, or simply making your regulars feel seen.
How to implement it:
- Add signage or displays that show your local roots — like photos, team shoutouts, or pet-of-the-month features.
- Offer services like local delivery, curbside pickup, or order-ahead.
- Share real customer stories, both online and in store.
How your POS helps:
A comprehensive POS system lets your customers schedule services like grooming, boarding, or training directly from your website. This gives them the convenience of larger retailers, while maintaining the personal touch of a local store. Plus, it saves you time by automatically keeping your calendar updated, so you don’t have to handle every call or worry about double bookings.
Local SEO tip:
SEO (search engine optimization) can boost your online visibility. Update your business listings to reflect your store’s voice and personality. Use phrases like “locally owned” or “[City]’s trusted pet shop,” and make sure your info is accurate across all platforms. That way, local pet owners are more likely to see your store pop up in search results.
Related Read: What Is Pet Store SEO? (+ 10 Beginner-Friendly Tips)
Market Smarter With eTailPet
Marketing is easier when your POS system is built for the pet industry. eTailPet gives independent pet retailers the tools to compete — and win — without juggling multiple systems.
From one platform, you can segment customers by pet type and purchase history, automate email campaigns for birthdays and reorders, and schedule social content. You can also manage subscriptions and loyalty programs, track low-stock alerts, and even autofill purchase orders to avoid last-minute scrambles. Need to offer local delivery? You can set your delivery radius and keep your online inventory in sync with in-store stock.
All of it works together — so your marketing, operations, and customer experience stay connected.
Ready to see how it works? Schedule a free demo today.
